Italy doesnt have a ban on double jeopardy in its legal system, and tuesdays decision reopens the acquittal of knox and raffaele sollecito in the 2007 murder of knox s roommate, meredith kercher. Double jeopardy is a procedural defence that prevents an accused person from being tried. But under the italian criminal justice system, the prosecution couldand didappeal knoxs acquittal. But under the italian criminal justice system, the prosecution couldand did appeal knoxs acquittal. Nina burleigh, who wrote a book on the knox case and frequently. Amanda knox and italys carnivalesque justice system. When a defendant is convicted, and requests a new trial, they waive double jeopardy protections and a second trial is allowed. Amanda knox has faced three verdicts in six years over a case in which it. Double jeopardy laws in question over italian courts second murder trial for meredith kercher. The second trial resulted in a second guilty verdict on january 30, 2014for both knox and her former flameand a sentence of 28 years in. The fifth amendments double jeopardy provision meant that ignatow could not be tried again, although he was given some prison time for perjury.
Some experts say it is unlikely that knox will be extradited to italy at all because of u. Her latest trial in italy, if it does happen, wouldnt start until 2014. The appellate court then retried knox, heard additional evidence and acquitted knox. There is no habeas corpus, no protections against selfincrimination, no prevention of double jeopardy, and no right to a speedy trial. He also doubts that the united states would want to set a. Italian judges order retrial for amanda knox in murder. Knox as the double deviant according to frigon 1995, 28, women who commit crimes not only offend against the law but also against social and moral values and roles.
Italys highest court will soon decide whether to overturn or uphold the murder conviction of amanda knox. He has already released a book about his experience. Knox and sollecito were convicted of murder and sexual assault in the first trial based on dna evidence, confused alibis and knox s false accusation against a congolese bar owner, for which she. But under the italian criminal justice system, the prosecution couldand didappeal knox s acquittal. In the united states, the principal of double jeopardy would have prohibited another appeals round after her acquittal. Does the constitution protect amanda knox from a murder retrial.
The fifth amendment includes a double jeopardy clause stating that no person be subject for the same offense to be. At common law a defendant could be exposed to jeopardy for the same offense only once. Harry the hook aleman january 19, 1939 may 15, 2010 was a chicago mobster who was one of the most feared enforcers for the chicago outfit during the 1970s. Last week, a court in italy found amanda knox and raffaele sollecito guilty of the 2007 murder of meredith kercher in perugia. Amanda knox s second murder trial kicks off in italy without her. Double jeopardy protects americans but not italians. Italys highest court overturns amanda knox acquittal in. The amanda knox case is one of the strangest legal battles youre. Amanda knox trial nears 3rd verdict washington times. Amanda knox ruling by italys highest court could lead to new legal. Double deviance and the bad woman georga mankarious.
This was the third trial of the evidence against the pair and it. This was the third trial of the evidence against the pair and it is clear that knox and sollecito are innocent. This demonstrates the key argument of the double deviance theory. Its true that one of the reasons the amanda knox trial was such a worldwide media sensation is, in part, due to italys legal system, which doesnt allow for the american concept of double. Her version of the case in book form, waiting to be heard, is coming out in april from harpercollins. As a result, knox and sollecito were once again put on trial. Knox may be ordered to return to italy for the retrial, to be heard in an appellate court in florence. That is a greater sentence than she was given in 2009.
Penguin books, on the spellbinding amanda knox case, has been reprinted with an. No judgment is considered final in italy until all appeals have been exhausted. The italian supreme court overturned the acquittals of knox and her former boyfriend. Rome italys highest criminal court ordered a whole new trial for amanda knox and her former italian boyfriend on tuesday, overturning their acquittals in the gruesome slaying of her british roommate.
Then, it was 26 years and she served four years of the sentence before being released in 2011. Italian high court overturns acquittal of american student accused of murder italys highest court has overturned the 2011 acquittal of amanda knox, the. Amanda knoxs epic legal nightmare business insider. Knox is also the subject of an exclusive interview with abcs diane sawyer to be aired on april 30.
Knox was convicted, then her conviction was overturned on appeal, and then the appellate court judgment was reversed, and a new trial ordered albeit at the appellate level. Amanda knox and double jeopardy outside the beltway. Americans, most of whom have never been charged with a criminal offense, find italy. The meredith kercher case is framed by prejudice as much as. Double jeopardy a key question if amanda knox pursued in us how would us react to any extradition request seeing as it is based on a retrial. To be clear, the double jeopardy clause of the fifth amendment protects people in the united states from being tried twice for the same crime. We have been reminded of this defense from television, movies, and books. At the same time, the trials have left the kercher family without clear. What we have learned from this case is that italian justice leaves a lot to be desired. Double jeopardy a key question if amanda knox pursued in us.
They will now face a third trial because italy, like many other countries, does not recognize the defense of double jeopardy. Yesterday, the italian appellate court sentenced amanda knox to 28 years and six months in prison. Amanda knox, double jeopardy, and innocence california. Italys highest court overturns acquittal in murder case. Amanda knox will be tried for murder again after being aquitted in italy. Italian high court overturns amanda knox acquittal the. However, jeopardy attaches at the trial court level, upon an acquittal. For instance, lawyer martin friedland, in his book my life in crime and other. Double jeopardy a few different media outlets have been reporting that it may be double jeopardy under us law for knox to be tried again. Supreme court justice hugo black wrote about the reasons for the prohibition against. Hill, a louisville courierjournal columnist, has done an outstanding job of showing how the case developed and what went wrong. Double jeopardy laws in question over italian courts.
Amanda knox, raffaele sollecito and the nightmare of italian justice. Unclear if amanda knox s fifth amendment rights will prevent possible extradition cbs news if amanda knox is extradited for the same crime of. Dershowitz believes double jeopardy would not be an issue because knox s acquittal was not a final judgment. The verdict in amanda knox s appeals trial is expected today around 4 pm pst 2 pm on the east coast. Lots of media coverage of amanda knox, but almost no one.
What should really be on trial is the italian justice system. Italy doesnt have a ban on double jeopardy in its legal system, and. Knox is fortunate shes american, and fortunate she committed her crime in a country that presumed her innocent until proven guilty and that gave her and her legal team every opportunity to defend herself in a court of law. Her version of the case in book form, waiting to be heard, is coming out. Amanda knox retrial begins amanda knox s second trial over the murder of her british roommate meredith kercher has begun, but knox is not present at court in florence. More recently, there are claims that knox will never be extradited due to the double jeopardy clause of the fifth amendment. Knox attorney dalla vedova dismissed the double jeopardy concern, insisting the high court ruling tuesday hadnt decided anything about the defendants guilt or innocence, but. In the excellent book on the case, the fatal gift of beauty. Knox may be ordered to return to italy for the retrial, to be.
Though not as well known as the double jeopardy prohibition. So, for example, the us would not extradite knox if it felt the italian trial would expose her to double jeopardy a concept that violates the us constitution. This means the earliest possible date for a new trial would be july. Finding her guilty again is justice, not double jeopardy. Once all appeals have been exhausted on a case, the judgement is final and the action of the prosecution is closed code of penal procedure, art. Throughout her book knox insists that the reason she fell under suspicion was because. State department, and the issue is likely to stir debate over whether she is a victim of double jeopardy. Italian court orders retrial for murder case involving. In february of 2012, knox agreed to write a book about her experiences while on trial, convicted and acquitted for murder. Amanda knoxs murder conviction reinstated in italy. The publicity over the knox case isnt expected to slow down. Rome cnn italian supreme court judges ruled tuesday that american amanda knox should stand trial again for the death of her former roommate in italy. Dont be so sure about it the idea that amanda knox was subjected to what we consider double jeopardy doesnt seem to withstand scrutiny. Our double jeopardy provision prohibits the government from appealing an acquittal.
In the knox case, its not at all clear to me that what has happened actually violates what our legal system would consider double jeopardy. In the united states protection from criminal double jeopardy is a. Double jeopardy no impediment to knox retrial mahoney. If knox and raffaele sollecitos 2014 guilty verdicts for the murder of meredith. Does the constitution protect amanda knox from a murder. After a lengthy trial in perugia, knox and sollecito were convicted of the murder in. Knox case has put the italian legal system on trial in the us. List of books and articles about double jeopardy online. In america, it is illegal to prosecute a person for the same crime. This is not double jeopardy, either under italian law or us law. A day after it was revealed that italys supreme court seeks to retry seattle resident amanda knox for the 2007 murder of british student meredith kercher, questions of double jeopardy have arisen. The appeal is held of amanda knox over the guilty verdict in the murder of. Amanda knox had been an awkward, overweight kid with acne before her trip to italy, a recent article in rolling stone reports.
444 1408 298 859 448 847 126 648 37 404 588 697 939 638 1127 413 238 1167 1301 708 1159 410 1148 552 1547 1321 1369 645 1587 703 1244 594 941 159 464 459 800 1414 208 1465 1360 1259 1423 533 992 551 926 940 260 176